A recent study from the University of Birmingham reveals that simply banning smartphones in schools may not effectively address the negative impacts of phone and social media use on students. This landmark research, published in Lancet Regional Health Europe, provides critical insights for educators and school administrators at AISL Mall.
Key Findings
- Ineffectiveness of Bans: The study, which included data from 1,227 students across 30 schools in England, found that schools with restrictive phone policies did not show improvements in mental health or overall well-being compared to schools with permissive policies.
- Minimal Impact on Usage: While smartphone bans resulted in a slight decrease in phone usage during school hours—about 40 minutes less on phones and 30 minutes less on social media—the overall time spent on these devices outside of school remained unchanged.
- No Improvement in Mental Health Outcomes: The research indicated no significant differences in mental well-being, anxiety and depression levels, physical activity, sleep quality, or educational outcomes (English and Maths attainment, disruptive classroom behaviour) among students from schools with and without bans.
- Link Between Usage and Well-Being: The study did find a correlation between increased smartphone and social media use and negative outcomes, including poorer mental health, lower physical activity, and reduced sleep quality. This suggests that reducing overall screen time is crucial for improving adolescent health.
- Need for Holistic Approaches: Dr. Victoria Goodyear, the study’s lead author, emphasised that addressing smartphone use should extend beyond school policies to encompass students’ overall daily usage patterns, both inside and outside of school.
Conclusion
The findings from this research challenge the effectiveness of smartphone bans alone in promoting student well-being. Instead, a more comprehensive approach to managing phone and social media use throughout the day is necessary to support the mental health of adolescents.
For further details, you can read the full study here: University of Birmingham Research on Smartphone Bans.
Health and Wellness products and services that may be of interest:
Get a special discount by quoting code AISLMALL during CHECKOUT.
Allied Health School Services Program – Parents workshop (90 mins)
In 2023, ISS and OST Therapy launched the Allied Health School Services Program. The AHSS team offers personalized workshops for parents, focusing on speech/language skills, cognitive play, behaviour management, and building resilience. These workshops provide practical strategies to help parents support their child’s development and create a positive home environment.
Caritas – Counselling Services
Caritas Human Empowerment & Achievement Training (HEAT) offers counseling for marital issues, extra-marital affairs, divorce, and marriage enrichment. Services include family mediation, sex therapy, support for family conflicts, and therapy for emotional, behavioural, and learning issues in children, as well as mood, stress, anxiety, and trauma.
Health & Wellbeing – Deck of cards
Dr. Christopher Willard’s mindfulness decks offer exercises for emotional well-being, including *Mindful Parenting*, *Self-Love*, and tools for teens to manage depression, anxiety, and build resilience. Each deck provides practical mindfulness strategies for emotional growth and mental health at every life stage.
Health & Wellbeing Videos
Unlock mindfulness and communication skills with expert-led courses. Topics include fostering positive family dialogue, boosting academic performance through mindfulness, and age-specific practices for preschoolers, primary students, and teens, promoting focus, emotional balance, and resilience.
iLiving: Initial 90-minute Consultation with Supported Healing for Children
iLiving is a holistic wellness centre that offers integrated services for personal transformation. They provide a comprehensive approach to address both physical and mental health, focusing on modalities like bioresonance, life coaching, family constellations, and more to help clients achieve optimal well-being. This consultation includes health scan of a child who is suffering from chronic physical or mental health challenge and coaching to their caretaker/parent(s).
KFBG Transformative and Mindfulness Forest Immersion Walk
Kadoorie Farm and Botanic Garden (KFBG) delivers inspiring, awareness-shifting and transformative programmes with potential life-changing experiences. We offer an opportunity and a peaceful space in the natural environment of KFBG for participants to experience, to rethink, to identify and to be able to deeply connect and appreciate Gaia, our mother Earth, and the interconnection and interrelationship that we share with her. By being close to, and having a respect for nature, through our transformative workshops, people can experience a sense of deep happiness and spiritual contentment in which could facilitate a more holistic way of living.
Llegend – Diploma in Professional Aromatherapy
This aromatherapy course covers essential oils, anatomy, and therapeutic applications, combining theory and practice. Accredited by the IFA, it offers exemptions for the UK TQUK Level 4 Certificate. As Hong Kong’s leading college for aromatherapy, it boasts 7 international accreditations.
Therapy Services – 1 on 1 Offline Therapy Service
In 2023, ISS and OST Therapy launched the Allied Health School Services Program. Our certified speech-language pathologists and occupational therapists offer personalized therapy for speech, language, motor skills, emotional regulation, and self-care. We use evidence-based practices to support students’ academic and social growth, boosting confidence and promoting inclusive learning environments.
Wellbeing Books Series
Dr. Willard’s books blend mindfulness with practical approaches for families. Alphabreaths teaches kids mindfulness through ABC-themed breathing exercises, while Growing Up Mindful offers parents and educators tools to help children build resilience, self-awareness, and empathy through mindfulness.
