A recent study from the University of Birmingham reveals that simply banning smartphones in schools may not effectively address the negative impacts of phone and social media use on students. This landmark research, published in Lancet Regional Health Europe, provides critical insights for educators and school administrators at AISL Mall.
Key Findings
- Ineffectiveness of Bans: The study, which included data from 1,227 students across 30 schools in England, found that schools with restrictive phone policies did not show improvements in mental health or overall well-being compared to schools with permissive policies.
- Minimal Impact on Usage: While smartphone bans resulted in a slight decrease in phone usage during school hours—about 40 minutes less on phones and 30 minutes less on social media—the overall time spent on these devices outside of school remained unchanged.
- No Improvement in Mental Health Outcomes: The research indicated no significant differences in mental well-being, anxiety and depression levels, physical activity, sleep quality, or educational outcomes (English and Maths attainment, disruptive classroom behaviour) among students from schools with and without bans.
- Link Between Usage and Well-Being: The study did find a correlation between increased smartphone and social media use and negative outcomes, including poorer mental health, lower physical activity, and reduced sleep quality. This suggests that reducing overall screen time is crucial for improving adolescent health.
- Need for Holistic Approaches: Dr. Victoria Goodyear, the study’s lead author, emphasised that addressing smartphone use should extend beyond school policies to encompass students’ overall daily usage patterns, both inside and outside of school.
Conclusion
The findings from this research challenge the effectiveness of smartphone bans alone in promoting student well-being. Instead, a more comprehensive approach to managing phone and social media use throughout the day is necessary to support the mental health of adolescents.
For further details, you can read the full study here: University of Birmingham Research on Smartphone Bans.
Health and Wellness products and services that may be of interest:
Get a special discount by quoting code AISLMALL during CHECKOUT.
Allied Health School Services Program – Screening plus brief report
In 2023, ISS and OST Therapy launched the Allied Health School Services Program. Together, we’ve built a team of certified, multi-lingual allied health professionals who quickly identify, assess, and support students with speech, language, learning, social, emotional, psychological, and behavioural challenges. Our goal is to enhance students’ communication skills and academic performance. Our team of allied health professionals offers unique insights that significantly benefit students with learning difficulties or disabilities.
Caritas – Counselling Services
Caritas Family Service, a non-profit organization serving the community for over 65 years, offers comprehensive professional development opportunities. These include clinical supervision, “Evidence-Based” counseling skills training, professional personality test training, and training sessions hosted by partner agencies. Through these diverse learning initiatives, Caritas empowers its professionals to provide impactful social services to individuals and families.
iLiving International
iLiving is a holistic wellness centre that offers integrated services for personal transformation. They provide a comprehensive approach to address both physical and mental health, focusing on modalities like bioresonance, life coaching, family constellations, and more to help clients achieve optimal well-being. The founder Anita S K Cheung has been recognised as one of Hong Kong’s Most Inspiring Residents and voted Best Alternative Healer multiple times. With her experience growing up as an unconventional child, Anita is passionate in bringing out the unique genius in her young clients.
Kadoorie Farm and Botanic Garden (KFBG)
Kadoorie Farm and Botanic Garden (KFBG) spreads over 148 hectares of land on the northern slopes of Tai Mo Shan, Hong Kong’s highest mountain. Surrounded by towering peaks, the site is rich with natural features, including streams, woodlands, orchards, vegetable gardens, walking trails, live animal exhibits, floral exhibits, sustainable agriculture demonstration plots, art exhibits, the Wild Animal Rescue Centre(WARC), a native tree nursery, conservation and education facilities, and magical, misty fern gardens.
Mindfulabs
Dr. Christopher Willard from Mindfulabs is a leading psychologist, author, and speaker specializing in mindfulness and mental health. A faculty member at Harvard Medical School, he has spent over two decades working with children, adolescents, and adults, offering practical, science-based approaches to enhance emotional well-being. Dr. Willard’s expertise lies in integrating mindfulness into education, parenting, and mental health care, making him a sought-after speaker and consultant worldwide.
